Someone BROKE IN While We Were Gone!!

We got home from our trip tired and ready to relax only to find that someone had broken in while we were gone! I have been so upset about this for the last two days that I haven't been able to post about it until now.

Mr. Man messed with the evidence and now we are at a loss for how to catch them. The police are no help and the neighbors say they didn't see or hear anything. Seems the little f'ers were quiet in their break in.

I didn't even really notice anything was amiss at first. Then my husband showed me this:

and all I can think of is this:

So now I need one of these:

I'm open for suggestions for the best way (read- not get my hands dirty or have to look at a cute little pleading mouse face) to get rid of our unwanted guests. Thank the Lord they are only in the garage!!